Between 1929 and 1933 the United States economy shrank by more than a quarter. Official figures put output in 1933 about 26 percent below 1929. This is the story of how that happened, why Americans argued about the cause, and how the country finally climbed out. We show the evidence, and the choice of what to conclude is yours.
Behind that number were people. In 1929, about 1.5 million Americans were out of work, roughly 3 percent of the labor force. By 1933 the number was about 12.8 million, close to 25 percent. These are Bureau of Labor Statistics estimates worked out later, because no monthly survey existed yet.
To understand how a country gets there, start in the fall of 1929. On October 24, a day called Black Thursday, a selling frenzy on Wall Street produced one-day losses of about 9 billion dollars. The following Tuesday, October 29, the market traded 16 million shares, a record that would stand for 39 years.
The Dow fell nearly 13 percent on Monday, October 28, and nearly 12 percent the next day. And the fall did not stop there. It kept sinking until July 8, 1932.
But a stock market crash does not by itself explain years of hardship, and economists still debate what did. One answer comes from the Federal Reserve's own history. It points to a wave of bank suspensions. From the fall of 1930 through the winter of 1933, it says, the money supply fell by nearly 30 percent. In other words, there was far less money moving through the economy.
The problem was not only American. The Federal Reserve also describes the gold standard as having carried deflation from one country to another. Britain left gold in September 1931.
Congress then made a choice that is still argued about. President Hoover signed the Smoot-Hawley tariff on June 17, 1930. The Senate had adopted the final version 44 to 42, and the House 222 to 153. Historians disagree about how much that tariff mattered to the Depression.
Whatever the mix of causes, the pressure showed most visibly at the banks. The Federal Reserve's tables count roughly 9,000 banks that suspended operations between 1930 and 1933, about 4,000 of them in 1933 alone. Suspended is not the same as failed, and some reopened.
Farmers were hit too, and in their own way. The Commerce Department reported that the gross income from farm production fell 58 percent from 1929 to 1932. That is the value of what farmers produced, not their profit.
By 1932 the economy had become the central question in American politics. On July 2, 1932, Franklin Roosevelt accepted the Democratic nomination and made a pledge that gave his program its name:
“I pledge you, I pledge myself, to a new deal for the American people.”
Meanwhile the anger was visible in Washington itself. That summer, thousands of veterans camped in the capital to demand early payment of a bonus. On July 28 the Army was ordered to clear the camps. The National Park Service says about 10,000 people, not all of them veterans, were still there, and they were driven off by cavalry with tanks and tear gas. Hoover gave his own account that day, saying that some 5,000 had taken an offer and gone home.
On August 11, 1932, President Hoover accepted the Republican nomination in a speech delivered in Washington. He described the country's situation this way:
“The last 3 years have been a time of unparalleled economic calamity.”
Voters made their choice in November. Roosevelt won 472 electoral votes to Hoover's 59. According to the American Presidency Project, he took about 57 percent of the popular vote to Hoover's 40.
Numbers like these are hard to feel, so here is what the Depression looked like to the people living through it. It did not hit everyone the same way. Letters to the Roosevelt administration show some of it. On February 19, 1934, Clyde Raymond Carhart of Norfolk, Virginia, wrote to the president about supporting his family. He said he wanted:
“to feed them on more than oatmeal and bread and get a start in this world.”
That letter is as printed by the National Archives. Not everyone lost work for the whole period, and that matters for the story. A railroad worker in West Virginia recalled decades later:
“I only lost, in that Depression, seven months without a payday.”
On the Great Plains, an environmental disaster added to the hard years. The National Park Service writes:
“The Dust Bowl was an environmental disaster that devastated the Great Plains region of the United States in the 1930s.”
For millions, the answer was to leave. The National Park Service says the Dust Bowl caused the largest migration in United States history, with over 2.5 million people leaving the Great Plains.
Some groups faced extra barriers. The National Archives notes that agricultural and domestic jobs were left out of National Recovery Administration codes, and that African American workers protested unequal pay for equal work.
Women faced pressure of their own. The Economy Act of 1932, signed June 30, required that when a federal department had to cut staff, a worker whose spouse also worked for the government could be dismissed first. The Hoover Library says that typically this meant wives would lose their jobs, because their husbands usually earned higher wages. That applied to federal jobs only.
This was the country Franklin Roosevelt took charge of on March 4, 1933. According to the Hoover Library, unemployment had reached 25 percent, and the banks were the first crisis he faced. His answer was to close them all. He declared a bank holiday that temporarily shut down the nation's banks, and Congress passed the Emergency Banking Act, which Roosevelt signed on March 9. The healthy banks were authorized to reopen on March 13.
On March 12, the night before the first banks reopened, Roosevelt spoke to the country by radio in the first of his Fireside Chats. He addressed whether it was safe to put money back in a bank. He said:
“I can assure you that it is safer to keep your money in a reopened bank than under the mattress.”
Did people believe him? The Federal Reserve's history says currency held by the public had increased by 1.78 billion dollars in the four weeks ending March 8. By the end of March, it says, the public had redeposited about two-thirds of that cash.
One listener, J. F. Bando, wrote to Roosevelt the next day, March 13, 1933, about the idea of speaking to the country this way:
“I thought what a splendid thing it would be if he could find time to do that occasionally.”
Reopening the banks was a rescue. Keeping the same thing from happening again was the job of the Banking Act of 1933, signed June 16, which created federal deposit insurance. Insurance took effect on January 1, 1934, covering up to 2,500 dollars for each depositor. The Federal Deposit Insurance Corporation says only nine banks failed in 1934, compared with more than 9,000 in the preceding four years.
The next problem was work. The Civilian Conservation Corps was signed on March 31, 1933. The National Park Service says it put hundreds of thousands of idle young men aged 17 to 28 to work.
In April 1935 came a far bigger effort, the Works Progress Administration. The Library of Congress says Roosevelt set it up to relieve the economic hardship of the Great Depression, and that before it was disbanded in 1943 it employed more than 8.5 million people on 1.4 million public projects, including roads, bridges, schools and parks.
Another New Deal law dealt with labor. The Wagner Act, signed on July 5, 1935, gave employees the right to form and join unions, and it required employers to bargain with a union selected by a majority of their employees. The National Labor Relations Board says the law was meant to enforce those rights rather than just mediate disputes.
Then, on August 14, 1935, came Social Security. It passed the House 372 to 33 and the Senate 77 to 6, and Roosevelt signed it as H.R. 7260. The Act's own opening words show that it was meant to do more than pay pensions. It was:
“An act to provide for the general welfare by establishing a system of Federal old-age benefits, and by enabling the several States to make more adequate provision for aged persons, blind persons, dependent and crippled children, maternal and child welfare, public health, and the administration of their unemployment compensation laws; to establish a Social Security Board; to raise revenue; and for other purposes.”
In plain terms, the Act set up federal old-age benefits for people past working age, and it gave the states money for old-age assistance, unemployment compensation administration, aid to dependent children and aid to the blind.
Not everyone agreed that the government should do so much. Critics on the right organized. The American Liberty League's 1934 statement of principles, as transcribed by the Bill of Rights Institute, says:
“There can be no defense of bureaucracy.”
Former President Hoover made the same kind of argument in 1935:
“We cannot spend ourselves into real prosperity.”
Others said Roosevelt had not gone far enough. From the left, Senator Huey Long said in a February 1934 radio address:
“We have to limit fortunes.”
So the argument ran in two directions at once, and the economy did not settle it. The recovery stalled. In 1937 and 1938 real GDP fell about 10 percent and unemployment climbed back to about 20 percent.
What finally ended the crisis was the war. The Federal Reserve says the recovery culminated during World War II. Real GDP was about 1,256 billion dollars in 1937 and about 1,681 billion in 1941, in 2017 dollars.
Unemployment tells the same story. The Bureau of Labor Statistics annual table shows the rate falling from 9.9 percent in 1941 to 4.7 percent in 1942 and 1.2 percent in 1944. That table is a household survey that began in 1940, so these numbers are not directly comparable to the retrospective 1933 estimate.
On the day he took office, Roosevelt had told the country what he thought the first task was. In his first inaugural address, on March 4, 1933, he said:
“So, first of all, let me assert my firm belief that the only thing we have to fear is fear itself—nameless, unreasoning, unjustified terror which paralyzes needed efforts to convert retreat into advance.”
That is the Great Depression: a collapse in output, jobs and banks, a long fight over its causes, a set of new federal programs, and a recovery that arrived only at war. Many questions remain open, and we show every side so the choice is yours. Find more at politicalwatercooler.com.
Sources
- Federal Reserve History, Emergency Banking Act of 1933
- FDR Presidential Library, banking curriculum hub
- FDIC, A Brief History of Deposit Insurance
- National Labor Relations Board, 1935 passage of the Wagner Act
- Library of Congress, Today in History, April 8 (Works Progress Administration)
- The American Presidency Project, Roosevelt's inaugural address and fireside chat texts